« With the hurricane moving our way, have you ever had to administer to patients in a disaster situation? | Main | If you have experienced drug shortages in your practice, what specific drugs were they? »

September 10, 2011


Frank Raymond, MD

Until 2001, 9/11 was my father's birthday. After that year, I don't recall any more parties on that day.

At the time of WTC attacks I was an ED /Ambulance Director for a nearby NYC hospital. As one of the first responders, I brought a team of ten or so residents to Ground Zero. Although I have many memories/stories of those first few days, this is one that I think back upon most often at this time of year.

There was no lack of generosity from the surrounding business community in giving support to the rescue workers. When it came to feeding us, there was a tremendous outpouring from all the surviving downtown restaurants, delis, etc, and I recall being perplexed by the surreal nature of being confounded by such an abundance of fresh, hot gourmet food against the grey ash backdrop of the most horrendous disaster that I had ever witnessed. Utterly overwhelmed by the surrounding destruction, I nonetheless was able to appreciate the irony of being unable to choose between the gazpacho and the bisque.

That was until I was approached by a young lady bearing a cooler filled with dozens of foil wrapped squares, apparently sandwiches. She explained that her third grade class had hastily made these peanut butter and jelly sandwiches to nourish and comfort the rescuers. Of course I took a couple, mostly out of guilt, and stuffed them in my labcoat pocket. As I returned to my aforementioned prandial dilemma, I decided to have a look inside the Reynolds Wrap, out of respect for the Third Graders, before I tossed them.

As I unfolded the foil, there was revealed within, something which I had not been forewarned nor could I have anticipated: accompaning each sandwich was a note written in the hand of a small child on a piece of jelly stained loose-leaf paper. Each PB&J sandwich bore a stark and heartfelt message of encouragement and of camaraderie, each achingly personal, signed by a frightened third grade child.

I choked down the remaining heel of soggy Wonderbread as I first ascended, and then descended down the crater's rim that had yesterday been the North Tower, to rejoin the Tactical Audio Rescue Unit of the NYPD in the hope of hearing the tap or wimper of a survivor. I felt now as if I were tethered to that child that made me my lunch on 9/12.

Barry Belgorod, M.D.


My 9/11: An Ophthalmologist at Ground Zero
September 9, 2011 2:02 PM

Having witnessed the Twin Towers’ collapse and later that day, the unfortunate lack of injured being brought to the New York-Presbyterian Hospital ER, I was determined to do whatever I could to relieve the suffering of survivors and responders on-site, at Ground Zero.

I was given a slit-lamp microscope, surgical instruments and emergency supplies by the Manhattan Eye, Ear and Throat Hospital, which I dissembled and transported to lower Manhattan. After being escorted through multiple NYPD, State Police and Army checkpoints, the NYPD provided me with a room at One Police Plaza, adjacent to the old NYC Command and Control Center, to treat hundreds of eye injuries in my improvised eye ER. Looking out of the window revealed devastated buildings, and streets that resembled a grey snowstorm.

As soon as the word got out that there was an ophthalmologist in the building, a long line of the injured formed outside the door. There were pulverized concrete and sheet rock fragments, wisps of fiberglass, asbestos dust and miniscule splinters of glass in hundreds of people’s eyes, microscopic removal of which, was challenging, but imperative.

During the second week, an officer from the police chief’s office personally escorted me around Ground Zero. After suiting-up with a hard hat, respirator mask, boots and rain poncho, the devastation appeared far more massive up close. The dedicated bucket brigades on “the pile” looked like ants on an anthill, with acrid smoke rising from the thousand-degree fires still burning underneath.

Falling building fragments had crushed the Winter Garden. A solitary steel girder was impaled into the side of a neighboring building, hundreds of feet above the ground. Huge machines cut though twisted steel, like scissors through paper. Cranes and bulldozers picked away at debris everywhere. The rain created ankle-deep grey mud from the residual concrete dust in the streets.

I visited one of several makeshift morgues to learn about the identification of victims’ fragmented remains. We entered a medical tent on the corner of Church and Vesey streets, manned by paramedics from Boston, where we all listened together, in silence, to the Presidential Address to Congress over the radio. It was all the more moving, standing on that site, at that very moment.

I recall leaning over a floodlit, debris-gouged precipice, watching rescue dogs being sent through serendipitous, dark openings in the rubble, to search for survivors. I was asked to remain there, in case a physician was needed. Electrifying anticipation was unfortunately followed by disappointment, as there were so very few survivors to be discovered, thus compounding the tragedy.

It was inspiring to watch New Yorkers banding together to selflessly help one another in our mutual time of need.

Dr. Barry Belgorod is a Jonas Salk Scholar and the recipient of the Oliver Memorial Prize in Ophthalmology from the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. He is the father of two sons, and is an eye surgeon on the Upper East Side of Manhattan.

Art Fougner MD

I'll give you two recollections -

1. "Dad, I have to hang up now. We're being evacuated."
I finally heard from my son again 4 hrs later. I was lucky.

2. From the MSG benefit concert for the Police and Firemen, Mike Moran, NYFD: "In the great tradition of the Irish people, Osama Bin Ladin, you can kiss my Royal Irish Ass."

The comments to this entry are closed.

May 2013

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  


  • Terms of Service
    The Medical Society of the State of New York (MSSNY) is not responsible for material posted by any individual on this site and does not warrant nor guarantee the content, accuracy, or use of the content in the communities. MSSNY specifically disclaims all liability for claims or damages that may result from any posting by members or non-members. MSSNY reserves the right to remove any materials it considers objectionable and that are posted by any individual on this site or that are e-mailed by site users to any other persons. MSSNY accepts no responsibility for the opinions and information posted on this site, whether by MSSNY or any third party. Such opinions do not necessarily reflect the policies of MSSNY. In no event shall MSSNY be liable for any special, indirect, or consequential damages or any damages whatsoever resulting from loss of use, data, or profits arising out of or in connection with the use or performance of any information posted on this site. MSSNY Community Forum Guidelines 1. MSSNY members and non-members can post messages. MSSNY members and non-members must enter their name and e-mail address, or they cannot be accepted. 2. Users should not attempt to sell or post unsolicited advertising, promotional materials, or other forms of solicitation to the group. MSSNY does not accept advertisements and/or product announcements from outside publishers, producers of software, or other vendors or commercial entities posted by members. Announcements of resources or conferences are acceptable as long as they are relevant to the interests of the community membership. Try to keep these brief. Questions and discussion initiated by community members about products or services are appropriate, but please keep in mind the common courtesies described in the Etiquette section. This provides a forum for help and recommendations among colleagues on the list. 3. Members should not post any information or other material protected by copyright without the permission of the copyright owner. By posting material, the posting party warrants and represents that it owns the copyright, if any, with respect to such material or has received permission from the copyright owner that covers such posting. In addition, the posting participant grants the MSSNY and its users of the community the perpetual, non-exclusive right and license to display, copy, publish, distribute, transmit, print, and use such information or other material. Any hypertext links and any reference to any products, services, or other information by trade name, trademark, supplier, or otherwise do not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, sponsorship, or recommendation by the MSSNY. MSSNY expressly disclaims liability related to the accuracy and content of other sites and use of any products or services referenced in the community or in a linked site. You are strongly encouraged to verify the accuracy and reliability of content of any other sites before posting links to such sites. 4. The MSSNY's policy is to comply with all antitrust laws, and the MSSNY reminds all users to guard against activity that could be construed as a violation of the antitrust laws. Do not post any material that:  references specific fees charged or paid for professional services.  discusses prices, discounts, terms or conditions of sale with regard to medical suppliers or other vendors or terms and conditions of provider agreements relating to reimbursement levels, bonus payments, and other price or cost-related items.  addresses salaries or terms of employment.  attempts to allocate patient markets or encourage collective or coercive activity with regard to third party payors, hospitals, other health care providers, or suppliers.  includes information that could otherwise be construed to impose a restraint on trade, inhibit free and fair competition, or organize a boycott. Do not assume that discussions are confidential or privileged. Do not post material without the permission of the copyright owner. MSSNY is not responsible for the accuracy or content of material on the communities. Etiquette on MSSNY Communities 1. Message Writing. Always use a clear, descriptive subject line. The more descriptive you are, the more likely people will read and respond to your posting. Please do not use generic subject lines such as "Help," "Need help," "Please help," "Need Info," "Request." When you respond to a posting, check the subject line to make sure it still reflects the topic at hand. If needed, retype an appropriate subject line. Please do not use ALL CAPS when submitting messages. Avoid (or explain) jargon, abbreviations or colloquial language that may be unknown to members. Try to keep postings as brief as possible. Avoid sending encoded messages and documents to the list. Post in plain text format. Do not send long documents directly to the list. Describe the document and give instructions for retrieving it, or offer to send it to those interested. If you have a web site, consider making long documents available for downloading from the web. When you wish to initiate a new discussion or request, do not use the "reply" feature of your e-mail program; instead, start a new message with an appropriate subject line. 2. Message posting. Proofread your messages before sending to make sure they are complete and say what you mean to say. Every posting should begin with a clear, concise introduction to the topic, or refer to the topic of a previous posting. There are often several "threads" of discussion going on simultaneously, which makes unreferenced postings confusing to readers. Please stay on topic when posting. The community is used for addressing what is related to that particular community's topics and issues. Comments concerning topics other than that, while interesting, belong somewhere else. A popular way of providing context is to quote verbatim from the original message. Please keep the quotations *short* and *relevant*. Cut out unnecessary text and repetitive signature information from previous senders. It would be a mistake for participants to assume that the community discussions are confidential or privileged. It is certainly possible, although highly discouraged, that comments made on the community could be forwarded to nonparticipants either by e-mail or hard copy transmission. Moreover, electronic communications are discoverable in legal proceedings. Likewise, statements made through the community could easily find their way into public policy debates about physician reimbursement, medical liability, or other topics affecting physicians, as well as specific coverage or reimbursement issues. Thus, participants should use discretion in forming comments, particularly with respect to confidential, proprietary, or otherwise sensitive information. 3. Common Courtesies. Kindness and consideration for others are prerequisites for community participation. Rudeness will not be tolerated. Members should not post defamatory, offensive, profane, threatening, abusive, or illegal materials on the communities. Debate about professional matters is welcome, but keep it polite. 4. Individual vs. public messages. If you want to respond to an individual and do not feel your comments are relevant to the group, please respond privately to that individual's e-mail address, not the community. Send personal messages directly to individuals by entering the individual's address in the "to" field. When you want to write to an individual, do not just use the "reply" feature of your e-mail system to respond to a message from the community - if you do, your reply will go to the whole list instead of the individual. Community members are often interested in others' queries, and appreciate reading answers to most questions; but, if you are soliciting multiple replies, such as in a survey or publication offering, as a courtesy you should ask for individual replies to your address. For some types of reference questions, you might want to solicit individual responses, but offer to summarize the responses for the whole list. This technique allows the information to be shared with the whole list, but in a summary form rather than in bits and pieces. Send individual "thank yous" privately; if you have received the information needed, it is courteous to send a "halt" message to the list to stop others from continuing to respond to a request (the person who provides the answer may also indicate that to the list). Other examples of messages that should be sent privately are requests for copies of offered materials, and "me too" messages (as in, "send me a copy of that, too"), survey responses, and very specific replies to questions that are not likely to be of general interest. Removal from MSSNY Communities The MSSNY reserves the right to terminate access to any member who does not abide by these guidelines.
Blog powered by Typepad